Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Allison Kara
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Allison Kara

2159 N Oak Dr
Suite 3
Plymouth, IN 46563

Corner of Highway 30 and Oak Drive, behind Sherwood Tire

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 12pm
1pm - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call us 24 hours a day!

Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting


2159 N Oak Dr
Suite 3
Plymouth, IN 46563


English, Spanish

I am glad you are here. I have been a State Farm Agent since 2010. I am not originally from Plymouth, but my daughter and I have made it our home since 2010. Many have seen my daughter grow up with me in the Agency and my team and I love that sense of community. I'd love to tell you more and hear about you someday. We hope you join our tribe - we want to know you too.

HOURS: Monday-Friday 9-12 and 1-5, why the break? We need to eat too! But don't worry - if you need to meet with us from 12-1 phone ahead and one of us will stay open to help you (we'll eat after).

AFTER-HOURS: We can meet with you on the weekends or evenings by appointment; call, text, or email us for available appointment times.

LANGUAGES: We speak Insurance - fluently, so you do not have to. Our goal, and focus, is making Insurance easy. Basically, if you have an insurance question – send us a text.

Yo estoy aprendiendo hablar espanol, pero mi Manager de Oficina si habla espanol.

24/7 We are always here to help you. We can do in-person appointments to answer your questions or meet with you virtually. Yes, we do have office hours...we like fresh air, sunshine, and we spending time with our family's too – but life can get hectic and we get that - if you need an evening or weekend appointment we will be here for you - just give us a call or send us a text and we can get you scheduled to sit down with one of us.

If you have made it this far - we think you are amazing and look forward to meeting you! You can keep reading (we appreciate the commitment) OR you can just give us a call or send us a text -help us help you.

RELATIONSHIPS DONE RIGHT: We treat everyone with respect and professionalism. We will meet you where you are comfortable - introverts of the world unite, we like to text too. Email is fine. Do you struggle with technology, feeling overwhelmed? That's okay - we like to help, stop in and we can set you up with State Farm apps. You want to be able to meet with your Agent? Pick me and my team. You don’t want to meet with your Agent? Pick me and my team. We are awesome.

INSURANCE BAGGAGE: Many have it - I see it often; bad experiences. My team and I want to help you ditch that baggage! We want you to understand your coverage's, your deductibles, and what your policy will do for you. But no worries, there will be no test.

WHY INSURANCE: We cannot predict the future and we do not have magic wands (we DO have a magic 8 ball) but we are great at personalizing plans and making sure you are covered so if there is a uh-oh you can breathe easy. Give us a chance.

HOW ARE WE THAT GOOD: We listen. We will meet you when/where/and how you are comfortable. Are you more of a face-to-face person? No problem, you can meet with me or a dedicated member of my team in person - just call in to schedule an appointment and avoid the waiting area. Not so people-y? That's okay! We can answer questions on the phone or via email. Do you have a phone phobia? You are not alone and it's perfectly okay-just let us know you prefer text or email.

WHAT WE ARE GOOD AT (or how we can help):

· Moving? Relocating?

· Leasing Office says you need Renters Insurance?

· Home, Auto, RV, Motorcycle, Boat, Scooter, Electric Bike, Life -one stop - we do it all.

· Starting a business?

· Can I insure that? Maybe – call us.

· Need a home quote because you are buying a house?

· How much will the new car cost? Text us - we will get you a quote.

SUMMER TIME - Yes, you should talk to us about the new toy (boat, e-bike, golf cart, motorcycle, etc.) that you bought. We can make insuring it easy.

If you want to know all about insurance, we will nerd out with you we can talk insurance for DAYS but you can leave it to us and go make some memories, we won't mind.

You made it to the end - did we just become friends?

Send us a text and find us on facebook - let's make it official.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself

To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.

Defensive driving tips

Speeding/offensive driving can lead to fatal car crashes. Learn defensive driving tips to stay safe on the road in this commonsense article from State Farm.

Benefits of disability insurance

Disability insurance helps when an injury becomes a total disability and you no longer work. It can help pay the mortgage, childcare & other daily expenses.

View More Articles

We provide honesty, respect, professionalism, and courtesy to all customers. My team and I combined have more than 30 years insurance experience. We speak Insurance-fluently. We are text-friendly for busy individuals juggling families, careers, and life.

My team and I treat everyone with respect and professionalism, and we want you to feel welcome. It is my team's goal to make our world easy for you to navigate - we speak insurance so you do not have to.

Brenda is my Office Manager; she has been with me for over 7 years. She is passionate about helping others and is always ready to help. Brenda is bilingual, licensed in multiple lines and has been an anchor to my team since her first day with me. If I am in an appointment or on the phone and you need an answer, Brenda can get it for you.

Becky is a solid member of my team, she comes to us with over 17 years in insurance, has been a part of my team for about 3 of those years and is always willing to help. She makes auto and home insurance easy and is a solid resource for farms and small business and she is always ready to answers questions and help our customers.

If you are not sure where to go or if we can help - call us, text us, stop in, or send us an email. We want to be your first stop for answers.

Brenda Herrera State Farm Agent Team Member

Brenda Herrera

Office Manager

I am a resident of Plymouth and have been a member of Allison's team since 2017. I am bilingual and it is my intention to help you find a coverage that will cover you and your business. Family is very important to me and because of that I am passionate about working closely with people to get to know your unique situation. I know life is fast paced and I am here to assist you in person, via text, email, or on weekends by appointment.
Becky Rhodes State Farm Agent Team Member

Becky Rhodes

Hello! My name is Becky, and I have been with Alli since the beginning, after a short hiatus from insurance to focus on my family I am thrilled to have reclaimed my spot on the esteemed team at Allison Kara State Farm in beautiful Plymouth, Indiana. I bring with me a passion for providing exceptional service and insurance assistance. I am married and have 2 adult children and one grand baby. I am all about family and living life to the fullest. I look forward to meeting you.